Charles River Associates CRAI
May 08, 2015 - 1:18pm EST by
zach721
2015 2016
Price: 29.10 EPS 0 0
Shares Out. (in M): 9 P/E 0 0
Market Cap (in M): 269 P/FCF 0 0
Net Debt (in M): 18 EBIT 0 0
TEV: 251 TEV/EBIT 0 0

Sign up for free guest access to view investment idea with a 45 days delay.

  • Professional Services
 

Description

Charles River is a 50 year old company that is a decent business that has understated its EBITDA due to a concept called forgivable loans. Adjusted to our estimates, we believe the company is inexpensively valued at approximately 6.5x EV/EBITDA. For 2015, management has guided to $310-320M in revenues with 16.5% Adjusted EBITDA margins or approximately $50 million while we believe EBITDA will be approximately $38M. We believe the company will generate  around $30M in FCF and if the company does not buyback stock, the company should end the year with ~$80 million in net cash or ~$9 per share (approximately 32% of market cap). Our investment thesis is based on CRAI reaching close to $5 in FCF per share over the next two years. This would require, a share count of 8 million (currently 9.2 million after repurchasing approximately 1 million shares in 2014) and FCF growing to $40 million. If this is achieved, we think the stock will be in the mid $50’s or upside of close to 100%.  Finally, we believe the downside is well protected with no customer concentration, approximately 6.5x EV/EBITDA, a very aggressive share repurchase of 10% in 2014 along with a continued high interest to repurchase shares, and a stable business with adequate liquidity and high quality employees.

 

We believe the stock is significantly undervalued due to the stock not screening to the true economics of the business due to a scary sounding concept called: “Forgivable Loans.” In 2012 and 2013 CRAI issued $60 million in forgivable loans to senior “Rain Makers” which amortize over 3-8 years. This is an employee retention tool essentially whereby compensation is paid upfront, however if the employee leaves the comp package is pro-rated and excess returned to the company. We understand that the issuance of forgivable loans is a recurring compensation expense; however, in 2012 and 2013, the company had issued 20.7M and 38.8M respectively, which we believe is higher than normal. The large issuance of forgivable loans will overstate amortization and understate EBITDA by approximately 5-7M for the next couple years, assuming they continue to issue 11M in forgivable loans a year.  Hence, we believe the current EBITDA of $30M is understated by 7M and the true earnings of the company are ~$37M and 12% EBITDA margins. With a current EV of ~$250 million, we think CRAI is fairly cheap. Essentially, the “Forgivable Loan” program understates EBITDA margins by 300 basis points over the amortization period.

 

On a ~$250 million EV, the company has $140 million in untapped lines of credit and nearly $20 million in cash. They have repurchased 10% of the company in 2014 or 971,515 shares at an average price of $26.27 per share. Furthermore, CRAI has another $20 million open to purchase additional stock in 2015 or approximately an additional 10%.

 

CEO October 2014:

Given our outlook for the business and the current valuation, quite frankly, it is sort of a no-brainer for us to be active purchasers for our shares. It's hard to find expected returns north of what we're experiencing through these share buybacks for shareholders. So we will continue to do that until we start seeing a closing of the value gap that can be observed in the marketplace.

 

 

CEO February 2015:

I think we were pretty aggressive throughout 2014 on the repurchase of those shares. Right there, our limit is really not as much on our appetite, as opposed to our ability given the trading restrictions on acquiring those shares. When we saw opportunities in the second half of 2014, we pursued them as vigorously as we could. There wasn't -- didn't have anything to do with limitations on capital or reluctance to use the remaining cash balances for those pursuits. We're going to approach 2015 in the same manner. What I see with what we've done, what I see in the prospects of the business, I still think CRA is a great value, and we're going to put our money behind that belief and continue to purchase those shares. Again, we face some restrictions given the general liquidity of the stock given what our repurchase ability is on a daily basis. But it has -- it really doesn't have to do with being capital constraint there. In 2014, we basically exhausted the cash generated by the business across the areas that were highlighted by Chad, both reinvestments in the business being able to drive growth there and the share repurchase. And I see a lot more of that in 2015.

  

While there is no investor presentation, the CEO hands out a four page flyer that he uses with clients. Top clients: Google (10+ projects going on currently), Pfizer, AT&T, CVS, Berkshire Hathaway, CAT, State Farm, Bank of America, Intel, Chevron, Best Buy, Valero, Apple, Amazon, Costco, Morgan Stanley, John Deere, Costco, GM, Wells Fargo, GE, Cisco, Oracle, HP, Wal-Mart, IBM, Exxon, Comcast, and Target.

 

No customer concentration over 5%.

 

The management team does not actively promote the company at conferences, in fact I can’t find a single investor presentation, however the company holds quarterly conference calls and is an aggressive buyer of their own stock:

 

 

The annual reporting is very clearly written. It is an easy and straightforward read. I do not want to paraphrase…a few key highlights:

 

We are often retained in high-stakes matters, such as multibillion-dollar mergers and acquisitions, new product introductions, major strategy and capital investment decisions, and complex litigation, the outcomes of which often have significant consequences for the parties involved.

 

These matters often require independent analysis and, as a result, the parties involved must rely on outside experts. Our analytical strength enables us to reach objective, factual conclusions that help clients make important business and policy decisions and resolve critical disputes.

 

Clients turn to us because we can provide highly credentialed and experienced economic and finance experts to address critical, tough assignments, with high-stakes outcomes.

 

Out of 451 employees, 75% have PHD’s or Master Degrees and are considered Senior Consultants which leads to revenue per employee of just under $700K or 2x industry comps.

 

The CEO is against acquisitions and the ability to internally innovate makes more sense than trying to integrate new people.

 

Given the quality of its employees, CRA is essentially launching an internal VC fund to invest in their employees most promising business ideas. I think this makes sense for several reasons.

A)      They have some track record of success such as https://www.globaldairytrade.info/ an online auction platform for dairy products. This is around a $10 million business with margins that are 2x core EBITDA margins 15%. It is not only about, consulting as the Global Diary Trade platform has proved.

B)       Second with utilization of just under 80%, employees bill 4 out of 5 days and are paid 5 out 5 days. So they have the time to potentially innovate.

C)       The employee base are some of the most accomplished experts in their given fields (average revenue per employee just under $700,0000) and have significant industry knowledge and opportunities especially if CRA can provide start-up capital.

 

 

CRAI

NCI

EXPO

HURN

FCN

TEV

            244

            860

            990

         1,741

         2,117

Net Cash

               17

           (177)

            145

           (492)

           (486)

Market Cap

            262

            683

         1,135

         1,249

         1,631

EBITDA Margin

12%

16%

24%

16%

12%

EV/Sales

0.79x

1.08x

3.39x

2.21x

1.20x

EV/EBITDA

6.62x

7.01x

14.16x

13.65x

9.92x

EV/FCF

10.22x

11.45x

19.44x

15.59x

26.62x

Sales/Employee

$ 683,293

 $ 159,777

 $ 298,046

 $ 277,820

 $ 395,824

 

 

Risks:

Employee utilization

Employee turnover of "rain makers" is a risk...but fairly low given long term forgivable loans. 

 

 

Disclosure: This does not constitute a recommendation to buy or sell shares of CRAI. We own shares in CRAI and we may buy or sell shares without updating this board. 

 

I do not hold a position with the issuer such as employment, directorship, or consultancy.
I and/or others I advise hold a material investment in the issuer's securities.

Catalyst

Back to strong margins and annual cash flow

continued aggressive share repurchses (10% in 2014)

Potential to generate $5.00 a share in FCF in 24 months

Not interested in acquistions but internal innovation to growth

 

    sort by   Expand   New

    Description

    Charles River is a 50 year old company that is a decent business that has understated its EBITDA due to a concept called forgivable loans. Adjusted to our estimates, we believe the company is inexpensively valued at approximately 6.5x EV/EBITDA. For 2015, management has guided to $310-320M in revenues with 16.5% Adjusted EBITDA margins or approximately $50 million while we believe EBITDA will be approximately $38M. We believe the company will generate  around $30M in FCF and if the company does not buyback stock, the company should end the year with ~$80 million in net cash or ~$9 per share (approximately 32% of market cap). Our investment thesis is based on CRAI reaching close to $5 in FCF per share over the next two years. This would require, a share count of 8 million (currently 9.2 million after repurchasing approximately 1 million shares in 2014) and FCF growing to $40 million. If this is achieved, we think the stock will be in the mid $50’s or upside of close to 100%.  Finally, we believe the downside is well protected with no customer concentration, approximately 6.5x EV/EBITDA, a very aggressive share repurchase of 10% in 2014 along with a continued high interest to repurchase shares, and a stable business with adequate liquidity and high quality employees.

     

    We believe the stock is significantly undervalued due to the stock not screening to the true economics of the business due to a scary sounding concept called: “Forgivable Loans.” In 2012 and 2013 CRAI issued $60 million in forgivable loans to senior “Rain Makers” which amortize over 3-8 years. This is an employee retention tool essentially whereby compensation is paid upfront, however if the employee leaves the comp package is pro-rated and excess returned to the company. We understand that the issuance of forgivable loans is a recurring compensation expense; however, in 2012 and 2013, the company had issued 20.7M and 38.8M respectively, which we believe is higher than normal. The large issuance of forgivable loans will overstate amortization and understate EBITDA by approximately 5-7M for the next couple years, assuming they continue to issue 11M in forgivable loans a year.  Hence, we believe the current EBITDA of $30M is understated by 7M and the true earnings of the company are ~$37M and 12% EBITDA margins. With a current EV of ~$250 million, we think CRAI is fairly cheap. Essentially, the “Forgivable Loan” program understates EBITDA margins by 300 basis points over the amortization period.

     

    On a ~$250 million EV, the company has $140 million in untapped lines of credit and nearly $20 million in cash. They have repurchased 10% of the company in 2014 or 971,515 shares at an average price of $26.27 per share. Furthermore, CRAI has another $20 million open to purchase additional stock in 2015 or approximately an additional 10%.

     

    CEO October 2014:

    Given our outlook for the business and the current valuation, quite frankly, it is sort of a no-brainer for us to be active purchasers for our shares. It's hard to find expected returns north of what we're experiencing through these share buybacks for shareholders. So we will continue to do that until we start seeing a closing of the value gap that can be observed in the marketplace.

     

     

    CEO February 2015:

    I think we were pretty aggressive throughout 2014 on the repurchase of those shares. Right there, our limit is really not as much on our appetite, as opposed to our ability given the trading restrictions on acquiring those shares. When we saw opportunities in the second half of 2014, we pursued them as vigorously as we could. There wasn't -- didn't have anything to do with limitations on capital or reluctance to use the remaining cash balances for those pursuits. We're going to approach 2015 in the same manner. What I see with what we've done, what I see in the prospects of the business, I still think CRA is a great value, and we're going to put our money behind that belief and continue to purchase those shares. Again, we face some restrictions given the general liquidity of the stock given what our repurchase ability is on a daily basis. But it has -- it really doesn't have to do with being capital constraint there. In 2014, we basically exhausted the cash generated by the business across the areas that were highlighted by Chad, both reinvestments in the business being able to drive growth there and the share repurchase. And I see a lot more of that in 2015.

      

    While there is no investor presentation, the CEO hands out a four page flyer that he uses with clients. Top clients: Google (10+ projects going on currently), Pfizer, AT&T, CVS, Berkshire Hathaway, CAT, State Farm, Bank of America, Intel, Chevron, Best Buy, Valero, Apple, Amazon, Costco, Morgan Stanley, John Deere, Costco, GM, Wells Fargo, GE, Cisco, Oracle, HP, Wal-Mart, IBM, Exxon, Comcast, and Target.

     

    No customer concentration over 5%.

     

    The management team does not actively promote the company at conferences, in fact I can’t find a single investor presentation, however the company holds quarterly conference calls and is an aggressive buyer of their own stock:

     

     

    The annual reporting is very clearly written. It is an easy and straightforward read. I do not want to paraphrase…a few key highlights:

     

    We are often retained in high-stakes matters, such as multibillion-dollar mergers and acquisitions, new product introductions, major strategy and capital investment decisions, and complex litigation, the outcomes of which often have significant consequences for the parties involved.

     

    These matters often require independent analysis and, as a result, the parties involved must rely on outside experts. Our analytical strength enables us to reach objective, factual conclusions that help clients make important business and policy decisions and resolve critical disputes.

     

    Clients turn to us because we can provide highly credentialed and experienced economic and finance experts to address critical, tough assignments, with high-stakes outcomes.

     

    Out of 451 employees, 75% have PHD’s or Master Degrees and are considered Senior Consultants which leads to revenue per employee of just under $700K or 2x industry comps.

     

    The CEO is against acquisitions and the ability to internally innovate makes more sense than trying to integrate new people.

     

    Given the quality of its employees, CRA is essentially launching an internal VC fund to invest in their employees most promising business ideas. I think this makes sense for several reasons.

    A)      They have some track record of success such as https://www.globaldairytrade.info/ an online auction platform for dairy products. This is around a $10 million business with margins that are 2x core EBITDA margins 15%. It is not only about, consulting as the Global Diary Trade platform has proved.

    B)       Second with utilization of just under 80%, employees bill 4 out of 5 days and are paid 5 out 5 days. So they have the time to potentially innovate.

    C)       The employee base are some of the most accomplished experts in their given fields (average revenue per employee just under $700,0000) and have significant industry knowledge and opportunities especially if CRA can provide start-up capital.

     

     

    CRAI

    NCI

    EXPO

    HURN

    FCN

    TEV

                244

                860

                990

             1,741

             2,117

    Net Cash

                   17

               (177)

                145

               (492)

               (486)

    Market Cap

                262

                683

             1,135

             1,249

             1,631

    EBITDA Margin

    12%

    16%

    24%

    16%

    12%

    EV/Sales

    0.79x

    1.08x

    3.39x

    2.21x

    1.20x

    EV/EBITDA

    6.62x

    7.01x

    14.16x

    13.65x

    9.92x

    EV/FCF

    10.22x

    11.45x

    19.44x

    15.59x

    26.62x

    Sales/Employee

    $ 683,293

     $ 159,777

     $ 298,046

     $ 277,820

     $ 395,824

     

     

    Risks:

    Employee utilization

    Employee turnover of "rain makers" is a risk...but fairly low given long term forgivable loans. 

     

     

    Disclosure: This does not constitute a recommendation to buy or sell shares of CRAI. We own shares in CRAI and we may buy or sell shares without updating this board. 

     

    I do not hold a position with the issuer such as employment, directorship, or consultancy.
    I and/or others I advise hold a material investment in the issuer's securities.

    Catalyst

    Back to strong margins and annual cash flow

    continued aggressive share repurchses (10% in 2014)

    Potential to generate $5.00 a share in FCF in 24 months

    Not interested in acquistions but internal innovation to growth

     

    Messages


    Subject20% Dutch Tender Announced Today
    Entry02/22/2016 09:06 AM
    Memberzach721

    Charles River Associates (CRA) Announces Commencement of Tender Offer to Purchase up to $30 Million of Its Common Stock

    Business Wire 
     
     

     

    BOSTON--(BUSINESS WIRE)--

     

    Charles River Associates (CRAI), a worldwide leader in providing economic, financial, and management consulting services, today announced the commencement of a modified “Dutch auction” self-tender offer to purchase for cash up to $30 million in value of shares of its common stock at a price within (and including) the range of $18.00 to $19.75 per share. The closing price of CRA’s common stock on Friday, February 19, 2016, the last full trading day prior to the commencement of the tender offer, was $17.14 per share.

    “Return-of-capital initiatives such as this buyback, and our existing share repurchase plan, are key elements in our capital allocation strategy,” said Paul Maleh, CRA’s President and Chief Executive Officer. “Today’s announcement underscores our confidence in CRA’s growth prospects and our commitment to provide value for our shareholders.”

    The tender offer will expire at 5:00 pm, Eastern Time, on Monday, March 21, 2016, unless extended by CRA. Tenders of CRA’s common stock must be made prior to the expiration of the tender offer and may be withdrawn at any time prior to the expiration of the tender offer.

    CRA intends to finance the tender offer with cash on hand and by borrowing under its existing revolving credit facility.

      Back to top