We are long shares of DDR, a retail REIT focused on power centers (typically 300-500k sq ft) which are often anchored by a mass merchant (Wal-Mart, Target, Costco- in many cases DDR is not the owner of the WMT/TGT/COST but is simply co-located) and/or home improvement retailer (HD/Lowe’s) and include a leading discount apparel concept (TJX/Ross) and may or may not include a grocery/Bed Bath & Beyond/Ulta.After declining 50% year to date (and down ~60% from post GFC high of $20), shares trade at attractive multiples (6.8x normalized FFO, ~9% cap rate, and 86% of stated book/53% of adj book) and we see 50+% upside. Shares have been beaten up as investors are concerned about:
Puerto Rican exposure - PR represents ~13% of NOI (pro-forma for YTD divestitures).
US retail REITs are out of favor - death of bricks and mortar retail, uptick in vacancy/slight decline in US NOI.The bankruptcies of Sports Authority/HH Gregg have added to vacancies this year (though the company has since received LOIs to let this space).
Historical declines in NOI/FFO due to divestitures - DDR is at the tail end of a multi-year asset divestiture program designed to de-leverage and reduce exposure to non-core/weaker assets.De-leveraging and paying down debt at 4-5% while selling assets at 7-8% cap rate is dilutive to FFO.
Bed Bath & Beyond exposure - similar to Brixmor (very good writeup here on VIC , BBBY represents ~3.8% of rents.There is also exposure to such investor favorites as OfficeMax/Staples (1.2% and 0.7%, respectively), Ascena (1.3%) and Toy’s R’US (1.2%).The top 50 exposures can be found on page 13 of the most recent supplement.
Writedown of exposure to preferred stock in a JV with Blackstone.
Well WeighingMachine, why do you own this?
We think there is inherent strength in the company’s significant exposure to A) strong retailers, i.e. WMT/COST/TGT/HD/LOW/TJX/ULTA/FIVE and (b) these retailers not only drive traffic but drive a high frequency of visits (necessities/TJ MaXX never the same place twice, etc).We believe that the benefits of being exposed to strong retailers will drive frequent traffic and allow management to re-let space at positive spreads as vacancies emerge and increase letting of vacant small spaces which have significantly higher ABRs.
Nearing end of major asset sale/divestiture phase.At 3Q, the company noted that it is looking to divest another $900 mn or so of assets
Management - DDR has been a revolving door with multiple management teams over the past few years.The current mgmt team (CEO/COO/CFO) come from Equity One which was sold to Regency Centers (REG) late last year.Management is executing on divestitures/de-leveraging and will soon shift its focus to re-development/operations (boosting smaller shop occupancy which it sees as a $40 mn NOI opportunity).
Improved balance sheet - the asset sale program has allowed DDR to bring its leverage ratio from to the current level of 6.3x (incl share of JV debt/income but excluding preferred) and will take the ratio below 6x.
We think the strong will get stronger as 1) customers gravitate toward locations offering a wide range of value priced products (2) financially strong players with access to the capital markets are able to continue to invest and renovate (3) strong leasing team focused on bringing in tenants which are NOI accretive and drive additional traffic to the location.
While the asset divestiture program has been dilutive to FFO, according to the most recent management presentation, divestitures have been done at lower cap rates than DDR trades - for wholly owned properties, divestitures have been done at 7.2% whereas we have the DDR enterprise trading at an 8.6% cap rate.
While the equity has declined 50% and trades at a 10% dividend yield, DDR has funded itself at attractive rates thus far in 2017 - most recently it sold 7 year senior unsecured at 4%. The company has extended its
Valuation - DDR trades at an 9+% cap rate, roughly 7x normalized FFO and sports a 10.2% dividend yield.We see a disconnect in how retailers (we are shorting a basket here) are valued vs. the valuation of DDR.While DDR optically looks considerably more levered than a typical retailer, the gap is narrowed when considering off balance sheet operating leases.
Here is my take on valuation:
DDR
$ mn
High
Base
Low
NOI
700
690
650
Cap Rate
7.0%
7.8%
8.5%
Value of Properties
10,000
8,903
7,647
+ Value of JV Prefs
327
327
327
Value of Enterprise
10,327
9,230
7,974
Less Net Debt, incl share of JV debt
4,374
4,374
4,374
Less Preferred
525
525
525
Less Minority Int
10
10
10
Value to Equity
5,418
4,321
3,065
Shares o/s
369
369
369
Value Per Share
14.68
11.71
8.31
Share price
7.40
7.40
7.40
Upside
98.4%
58.3%
12.2%
NOI
700
690
650
Less: Interest
174
179
183
Less: Pref Divs
33.2
33.2
33.2
Less: Maintenance Capex
40
50
65
Less: Central O/H
72
72
72
FFO
379
355
296
Steady state-ish FFO per share
1.03
0.96
0.80
Share price net of pref val p/s
6.51
6.51
6.51
Adj P/FFO
6.3
6.8
8.1
From the B/S
Equity to Common
3181
+Accumulated Depreciation
1942
Adj Equity
5123
Adj Equity per share
13.88
Implied Cap Rate at $7.40
9.6%
9.4%
8.9%
Risks
1) Bricks and mortar is dead and I’m an idiot for buying this.
I do not hold a position with the issuer such as employment, directorship, or consultancy. I and/or others I advise hold a material investment in the issuer's securities.
Catalyst
Retail relief rally spreads to shopping center REITs
Though I don’t see a deal getting done in the very near future, if the market doesn’t begin to see value here within the next 18 months, I would not be surprised to see the company sold.I think my base case would be a reasonable take-out price which would leave plenty of meat on the bones for a strategic acquirer.
Are you sure you want to close this position DDR CORP?
By closing position, I’m notifying VIC Members that at today’s market price, I no longer am recommending this position.
Flag DDR CORP for Removal
Are you sure you want to Flag this idea DDR CORP for removal?
Flagging an idea indicates that the idea does not meet the standards of the club and you believe it should be removed from the site. Once a threshold has been reached the idea will be removed.
You Cannot Submit Message ... Yet
You currently do not have message posting privilages, there are
1 way you can get the privilage.
You can apply for full membership by submitting an investment idea of your own. Or if you are in reactivation status, you need to reactivate your full membership.