|Shares Out. (in M):||135||P/E||18||21|
|Market Cap (in $M):||3,800||P/FCF||17||19|
|Net Debt (in $M):||426||EBIT||0||0|
|Borrow Cost:||General Collateral|
Sign up for free guest access to view investment idea with a 45 days delay.
DCI has historically been a highly valued, well-run company with a solid competitive position and fairly stable revenue stream driven by low priced after-market parts exposure. These types of businesses tend to hold up relatively well in downturns like these and hence generally deserve a premium valuation (it currently trades at 19x EPS when most of the rest of industrials trades at a market multiple or less). However, recent results and data points from competitors and customers suggest that there is no longer much room to hide and that DCI may soon also fall victim to earnings downgrades and multiple compression.
Simply, DCI makes filtration systems (air, exhaust, hydraulic, fuel, etc.) that go into engines and industrial applications along with the replacement filters for said systems. Their primary exposures are industrial construction (large industrial plants, etc.), off-road products (mining, agriculture), on-road products (large trucks), aero & defense and gas turbines. CAT is their largest customer at around 10% (but less than) of revs. They compete mostly with CLC and CMI. It is also a sleepy name in that it’s not all that well followed, doesn’t have a huge market cap and there isn’t a ton of liquidity. I believe this is what creates the opportunity.
To break down what’s happened in the space over the last several months, leading up to DCI’s last print. DCI printed its prior Q on 9/1 for the quarter ended 7/31 where they put up a beat with weak guidance, but not overly cautious commentary. 15 days later, their closest competitor (CLC) announced a huge whiff and guide down suggesting that the quarter (ended 8/31) got progressively worse into September. This was confirmed by CMI, who showed negative trends accelerating to the downside in their Filtration division (quarter ended 9/30). CAT has also since guided 2016 below the Street, citing revenues down 5%.
|CLC Revs||312.7||386.6||400.2||413.4||351.1||399.8||352.2||<<<Decelerated throughout the Q and sept|
This lead up to DCI’s last print, conveniently the day before Thanksgiving, where they missed top-line (down 10%), slightly missed EPS and guided down the year. In that print, their aftermarket business got slightly better (from -5% YoY decline last Q to -3% this Q) and their industrial business outperformed. Despite that and lower expectations for Q1 than any other Q this year, they still missed. On the call, they talked down their industrial segment, saying that their order rate slowed and was lagging their revenue recognition rate, and this should turn more negative going forward. Additionally, their on-road revenues remained bolstered driven by a strong year in truck sales in 2015, however they acknowledge that given recent order rates (ACT reported orders down 60% YoY in November, -40% in October, and most of the market expects truck sales to decline by 10%+ in 2016) pose risk to FH216 for them. They also talked about construction starting to disappoint. Finally, they plan to moderate share repurchases going forward given their current capital structure.
Despite this, their guidance assumes a similar revenue decline in FQ216 (10%) and a sizable rebound to flattish revenues for H216 despite most of their segments getting worse into H216. Hence, I think their guidance for FY16 remains fairly aggressive and needs to come down:
|FY16 - 9/1/15||FY16 - 11/25/15|
|Off-Road Products||Ag -20-10%, Mining -10-5%, Construction +LSD||CAT, Komatsu, Joy Global, Deere, CNH, AgCo|
|On-Road Products||+LSD||+LSD||Growth in H1||CMI, PACCAR, NAV…60% HD, 40% MD|
|Aftermarket Products||+LSD||Slight Decline||Driven by retention||30% AM is Trucks = Tonnage. 70% activity in other end markets|
|Aerospace and Defense Prod.||Comm up, Defense down|
|Indust. Filtration Solutions Prod.||+LSD||(2%)-(6%)|
|Gas Turbine Products||-13-9%||(11%)-(15%)|
|Special Applications Products||Slightly Down||Slightly Down|
|Total Revenue Growth||-2%-+2%||-4%||0%-(4%)||-4%|
EPS guidance is now for $1.49-$1.69 (down from $1.56-$1.76), which implies -6% to +7% growth. I think both of these are fairly generous given the headwinds mentioned above.
In Engines, based on what CAT said, recent commentary that 2016 could be even worse for CAT and DCI’s commentary that they are seeing construction get worse, I think revenues for that portion of the business is at risk of being quite a bit worse than they projected (+LSD in construction, -5-10% in mining). They are also expecting to be up in on-road., however recent commentary out of PCAR, Volvo and ACT suggest that NA heavy duty truck is likely to roll over pretty hard in 2016 (consensus currently projecting 10-15% declines). Aftermarket is their biggest and most stable segment, but it rolled over pretty hard the last two Qs (-5% and -3%), and given what’s happening to their end markets, it seems plausible that this segment is at risk of underperforming going forward.
In Industrial, management admitted that things are getting worse, and the magnitude of their guide-down is reasonable, it is plausible that this segment could get worse from here given capex trends across the board in industrial land.
On Margins, decrementals in H215 became pretty severe despite restructuring actions taken beginning in FQ215. They reportedly achieved $5M in run-rate savings in Q4 and think this will be closer to $7M through 2016, (maybe 50-100 bps incremental to FY16), but still experienced 24% decremental margins (though admittedly better than the 40% experienced in FQ315).
Looking out into FY16, the bottom end of their range seems to assume low teens decrementals while the high end of their range assumes 50% incrementals. Part of that is driven by the $45-50M in incremental restructuring benefits, however this is mostly offset by increase in comp expense, incremental investment and FX issues (it appears that they are potentially paying themselves a good portion of the benefit that they're receiving from implementing restructuring). They also just recently opened a new plant in Poland to serve the on and off-road markets. While Western Europe has proven to be a more resilient market and the impact of this is presumably baked into guidance, still somewhat of an odd time to be expanding.
I think revenues could be closer to down 5-6% organically, driven by further weakness in ag/mining and less exciting construction growth in off-road (13% organic decline in FY16 vs. 19% in FY15), new weakness in on-road driven by declines in NA truck (5% decline vs. 12% increase in FY15), a 5% decline in aftermarket driven by broad weakness across their end markets. If revenues are down closer to 5% organically and assuming a less onerous underlying decremental than is baked into guidance (ex. restructuring) and what they experienced last year of ~15-20%, you're probably in the $1.30-1.40 range. The bridge is as follows:
|Change in Revs||(189)||(189)||-5% Organic, -4% FX, +1% acq|
|FY15 Op. Inc||305||305|
|Decremental Margin||30%||40%||<<<FQ315 Decremental = 40%, FQ415 = 24%|
|Incremental Restructuring Savings||45||40|
|ERP System Investment||(2)||(2)|
|FY15 Op. Inc||271||247|
Hence, I think it's plausible that they disappoint this upcoming Q relative to Street numbers and could potentially bring down annual guidance.
Given that, I think the R/R is roughly this:
Though I'd say that there could be some downside to that multiple if they really put up that type of EPS number (FLS, which is supposed to have a similar aftermarket-type business model, suffered a 5x multiple reduction to multi-year lows throughout 2015 as numbers kept being revised lower and end markets deteriorated).
Additionally, I am beginning to view their governance as somewhat questionable. As I mentioned above, it seems that they're planning on paying themselves this year a majority of the cost savings being driven by the restructuring that they implemented last year, which is always fun. They also recently had to delay their 10-K filing due to past incorrect rev rec (potentially fraud), which on the margin creates some further concern over governance.
I think it's plausible that they disappoint this upcoming Q relative to Street numbers and could potentially bring down annual guidance.
Are you sure you want to close this position Donaldson?
By closing position, I’m notifying VIC Members that at today’s market price, I no longer am recommending this position.
Are you sure you want to Flag this idea Donaldson for removal?
Flagging an idea indicates that the idea does not meet the standards of the club and you believe it should be removed from the site. Once a threshold has been reached the idea will be removed.
You currently do not have message posting privilages, there are 1 way you can get the privilage.
Apply for or reactivate your full membership
You can apply for full membership by submitting an investment idea of your own. Or if you are in reactivation status, you need to reactivate your full membership.
What is wrong with message, "".