|Shares Out. (in M):||2||P/E||0.0x||0.0x|
|Market Cap (in $M):||145||P/FCF||0.0x||0.0x|
|Net Debt (in $M):||0||EBIT||0||0|
Sign up for free guest access to view investment idea with a 45 days delay.
Great Northern Iron Ore Properties (GNI) is a trust that owns interests in land on the Mesabi Iron Range in Minnesota. The land is leased to steel and mining companies that mine for taconite iron ore. The interesting thing about GNI is that it's guaranteed to go to 0 in April 2015, as that is when the trust dissolves. You will not make a fantastic return shorting GNI; on the contrary, you're not likely to generate an IRR much above high single digits.
(Before you read any further, a word of caution so you're not wasting your time: GNI only has 1.5M shares outstanding so it is hard, if not impossible, to short in size. It's also impossible to short on the classic discount brokerage platforms, i.e. Schwab, Ameritrade, E*Trade, etc. You can short probably ~100K worth if you work with a full service broker.)
Our thought process on GNI goes something like this:
The GNI Business Model
GNI's business model is simple. The trust owns land. It leases the land to steel companies - Cliffs and US Steel, to be exact. The companies mine the taconite ore on the land and pay GNI a royalty based on how much ore they've mined. The contractual price per ton paid for the ore is determined very confidentially and getting the information we got from management (above and beyond what can be gleaned from company filings) was like pulling teeth unsuccessfully. Here's what we found based on filings and our conversations with management regarding pricing:
(in pellet tons)
|Royalty per pellet ton||Iron & Steel PPI||All Commodities PPI|
GNI has precisely 20 cash distributions left to disburse to its trust-holders until the trust expires, i.e. precisely 5 twelve month periods to collect royalties and distribute. Additionally at expiration, trust-holders will receive in cash a final distribution equivalent to net liquid assets plus "principal charges" minus expenses and obligations of the trust upon termination. Net liquid assets is our terminology and refers to total assets minus total liabilities minus properties, while "principal charges" is GNI's term for the claim that present shareholders have on the trust properties. You can easily check the last few annual reports to see that this number does not move around very much and is presently at ~$12.5M minus those termination costs. We'll just assume no termination costs for now and use $12.5M for our scenario analysis.
We assume $2M in annual cash costs. This excludes the depreciation charges booked annually by GNI in its expenses and also adds in ~500K per year in interest and rent revenue. We're likely understating the costs by a bit here, but even if you add one or two million over the course of five years, it only increases your IRR by less than half a percent.
GNI will distribute all its royalties less expenses over the next five years. We take a look at a few scenarios below. Commentary follows.
|Base Case||Worst Case||Best Case|
|Average Royalty ppt:||3.00||3.50||2.50|
|Average Annual Shipments:||7.00||8.50||6.50|
|Average Annual Royalties:||21.00||29.75||16.25|
|Total Royalties ($mm):||105.00||148.75||81.25|
|Total Cash Costs ($mm):||(10.00)||(10.00)||(10.00)|
|Total Quarterly Distributions ($mm):||95.00||138.75||71.25|
|Final Distribution ($mm):||12.50||12.50||12.50|
|Total Distributions ($mm):||107.50||151.25||83.75|
|Total Distributions/ share:||71.67||100.83||55.83|
|IRR from short:||6.01%||-0.63%||10.59%|
In our base case scenario, we assume $2.70 in royalty-ppt in 2010 and 2011 and a 10% price increase annually afterword. This comes out to an average of about $3ppt over the five years. Again, this is a tad conservative as the 35% price increase over five years corresponds to a more than 70% increase in the Iron & Steel PPI off of the already high number of 2008. As for annual volume, we have a hard time seeing how volume goes much above 7M per year without an absolute rocket-ship of a recovery in auto production. If you look at the data on royalties and shipment we've presented above, you'll see that the change in pellet tons shipped on an annual basis is highly correlated to the change in annual auto production in the US. Even if we do see a vigorous overall recovery in the economy, that kind of auto production rebound is simply not in the cards.
In our worst case scenario, we assume $2.70 in royalty-ppt in 2010 and 2011, and a 20% price increase annually afterword. This comes out to about $3.50 ppt over the five years. We also assume average shipments of 8.5M pellet tons annually. We're not sure how either of these scenarios would possibly happen, but we guess it's conceivable that we go back to 2007-level US auto production and that the Iron & Steel PPI increases by over 100% from the 2008 highs over the next few years. Still, even in this case, you come out about flat.
In our best case scenario, we assume flat pricing over the next few years and higher production. We don't think this sort of scenario is as hard to come by as our worst case, but we do find it hard to believe that the Iron and Steel PPI will be flat over the next five years.
So you have a short idea here that should generate mid-single digit returns over time and that will also be a pretty decent market hedge over the medium term. The kicker here is that it's close to impossible to lose money. Maybe not the most exciting idea, but certainly a phenomenal risk/reward (i.e. none/moderate).
No catalyst - just time...
|show sort by|
Are you sure you want to close this position GREAT NORTHERN IRON ORE PPTY?
By closing position, I’m notifying VIC Members that at today’s market price, I no longer am recommending this position.
Are you sure you want to Flag this idea GREAT NORTHERN IRON ORE PPTY for removal?
Flagging an idea indicates that the idea does not meet the standards of the club and you believe it should be removed from the site. Once a threshold has been reached the idea will be removed.
You currently do not have message posting privilages, there are 1 way you can get the privilage.
Apply for or reactivate your full membership
You can apply for full membership by submitting an investment idea of your own. Or if you are in reactivation status, you need to reactivate your full membership.
What is wrong with message, "".