Smiths Group SMIN.LN
August 27, 2008 - 1:34pm EST by
2008 2009
Price: 10.97 EPS
Shares Out. (in M): 0 P/E
Market Cap (in $M): 4,255 P/FCF
Net Debt (in $M): 0 EBIT 0 0

Sign up for free guest access to view investment idea with a 45 days delay.


Smiths Group (SMIN.L – 1110p)

Founded in 1851, Smiths Group is a UK industrial conglomerate that consists of three high-quality, unrelated, and historically mismanaged businesses.  Philip Bowman, a new, best-in-class CEO, was recently brought in to restructure the company and ultimately break up the parts (likely in 2-3 years).  The 3 businesses, Detection, Medical and Specialty Engineering, generate a combined return on capital of 25% and organically grow earnings at 17%, 18% and 14%, respectively.  The SOTP valuation is 1850-1900p which suggests that the current price reflects a ~70% discount to intrinsic value.  In an uncertain macro environment, Smiths Group offers defensive business characteristics that provide an attractive return with limited risk.

Business Overview

Smiths Group is a conglomerate of three UK-based businesses. 

·         Detection: Detection produces sensors that detect explosives, chemical and biological agents, weapons, and contraband.  Smiths’ products include airport baggage detection devices that are located in numerous airports. Additional customers include military forces and public service workers who need to be equipped for chemical agent detection, critical infrastructure security (i.e. biological detection equipment), and by emergency services (detection devices for toxic accidents).

·         Medical: Medical produces medical devices for the hospital, emergency, home and specialist environments.  A large portion of these products are brand/reputation driven and have “practioner loyalty”; they are used for critical medical applications (intensive care, surgery, post-operative care during recovery, etc). The products range from vital care surgical products to drug delivery systems.  Examples of these products include anesthesia airway systems, endobronchial tubes, products for diabetics (insulin pumps, etc), catheters, dialysis-related products, and home infusion care products, etc.  Medical sells to 100+ countries and North America accounts for ~60% of Medical sales.

·         Engineering: Engineering consists of the following: 1) John Crane (majority of Engineering), a producer of mechanical seals for the oil, gas and petrochemical industry (high recurring revenue as they are largely replacement in nature), 2) Flex-Tek, a manufacturer of components that heat/move fluid for the aerospace, medical and industrial markets and 3) Interconnect, a manufacturer of highly-engineered electronic components (radio, etc) for the defense and telecommunications industries.


Investment Merits

·         New best-in-class CEO: Philip Bowman’s track record speaks to his relentless focus on shareholder value creation.  In his prior roles at Allied Domecq and Scottish Power, he successfully restructured and sold the businesses.  Now at Smiths Group, Bowman is highly incentivized – he will earn $4mm if he achieves his aggressive performance targets.  Better yet, he has a change of control payout of $6mm (divisional break-up constitutes a change of control) which provides further conviction in his intentions.

·         Significant scope for margin improvement: Under Smiths former leadership, a substantial amount of useless G&A costs were allocated to each of the three divisions resulting in artificially depressed margins.  Bowman will not only to remove the unproductive cost structure, but also to reclassify division margins to reflect division level profitability which will, in turn, unmask the potential value of each division to potential buyers.   Additionally, Bowman identified numerous opportunities to rationalize SKUs, improve working capital and increase prices.  When Bowman outlines his strategic plan in September, he will identify at least 500bps of margin improvement (through strategic turnaround and ultimate G&A removal).

·         Market leading defensive businesses with strong growth: Smiths businesses are all market leaders in their respective niches.  Detection and Medical both benefit from secular demand trends that are independent of the macroeconomic backdrop.  The industry for detection products is growing at 11% a year and Smiths has been growing double that pace.  If the EU/USA standardize airport security measures, Detection stands to benefit enormously as 450 new airports would have the capacity to purchase its technology leading baggage screening products. Engineering serves oil and gas markets, but its products are largely replacement in nature (70%) and do not depend on new capital projects.

·         Attractive valuation with clear market dislocation: The 15%+ growth and 30%+ ROIC of Smiths suggests the company should command at least an 18x multiple on an absolute basis and more likely 25%+ higher than that when factoring in the imminent breakup. Conservative expectations of the restructuring imply Smiths is currently trading at 10.5x post-turnaround earnings  (turnaround margins on 2008 sales) which suggests a 70% discount to intrinsic value.  The valuation dislocation exists for three reasons: 1) misperception of true profitability; former management allocated group G&A to each division – Bowman will reallocate costs and properly communicate profitability in September (SOTP models will immediately increase in value), 2) poor sell-side coverage due to small size (UBS offers the only decent assessment), and 3) Smiths is a show me story – Bowman has not yet communicated his strategic plan and has spent limited time with investors; once he outlines a strategy and begins to consistently execute, the market will gain conviction in both the margin and the break up, and rerate the stock accordingly.

Jun-06 Jun-07 Jun-08 Jun-09 Jun-10 Jun-11
Sales 737 691 719 762 807 856
EBITA 133 127 144 168 202 214
Margin 18% 18% 20% 22% 25% 25%
Detection Jun-06 Jun-07 Jun-08 Jun-09 Jun-10 Jun-11
Sales 412 438 534 631 744 878
EBITA 74 79 96 120 143 170
Margin 18% 18% 18% 19% 19% 19%
John Crane Jun-06 Jun-07 Jun-08 Jun-09 Jun-10 Jun-11
Sales 518 532 612 685 767 860
EBITA 66 75 92 123 169 198
Margin 13% 14% 15% 18% 22% 23%
Other Engineering Jun-06 Jun-07 Jun-08 Jun-09 Jun-10 Jun-11
Sales 513 500 490 515 540 567
EBITA 71 66 69 72 81 85
Margin 14% 13% 14% 14% 15% 15%
Consolidated Jun-06 Jun-07 Jun-08 Jun-09 Jun-10 Jun-11
Consol. Sales 2,180 2,161 2,355 2,592 2,859 3,161
Consol. EBITA 344 347 400 483 595 667
Consol Margin 16% 16% 17% 19% 21% 21%
SOTP Valuation (mm) Medical Detection Crane Other
2010 Sales 856 878 860 567
2010 EBITA 214 170 198 85
2010 After-Tax EBITA 160 128 148 64
Multiple 16.0x 18.0x 17.0x 13.0x
Valuation 2,568 2,299 2,521 830
Breakup EV 8,217  
Restructuring costs -75  
Asbestos Liability -100  
Debt -675  
Equity Value 7,367  
Shares 385  
Intrinsic Value £19.14  
Upside   74%    
2009E 2010E 2009E 2010E
OSIS 20.4 13.2 8.6 6.5
ASEI 22.9 20.5 10.7 9.7
COV 18.2 16.3 11.2 10.3
BDX 17.9 16 9.8 9.1
FLS 15.2 13.5 9.6 8.2
ROR.L 17.5 16.2 11.4 10.6

Investment Risks

·         Execution risk at Medical: Philip Bowman admitted that Medical “was a bigger mess than I had expected”.  While this means more potential for upside, it also suggests a higher level of execution risk for the turnaround at that one division.

·         Market conditions not ideal for a break up: Unlike other conglomerates, Smiths will not depend on a private equity bid for its assets – each of its three divisions would fit nicely with a number of strategic buyers with well-capitalized balance sheets. At the same time, private equity buyers can often bid up assets in an auction and ultimately cause these strategic buyers to pay more. If current market conditions prevail in two years, Bowman could struggle to get top dollar for the assets in the break-up.




(1) Meaningful restructuring plan to shed light on the true underlying profitability of the various businesses within Smiths; (2) Break-up of the company 18-24 months down the road.
    show   sort by    
      Back to top